top of page

When Feeling Becomes Too Much: Affect and Anxiety Regulation in Psychodynamic Therapy and ISTDP

2 days ago
6 min read

When Feeling Becomes Too Much: Affect and Anxiety Regulation in Psychodynamic Therapy and ISTDP


Working with difficult emotions in psychotherapy does not mean pushing someone to feel as much as possible.

In practising Intensive Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy (ISTDP), a form of psychodynamic therapy, it is important to recognise when the feeling of anxiety is interfering with a person's ability to experience and understand other emotions that may be driving the anxiety.


It is useful to distinguish between feeling an emotion, experiencing anxiety about that emotion, and an emotion being so difficult to tolerate that the individual becomes overwhelmed and struggles to think about what is happening.

A therapist needs to recognise this or there is a risk of mistaking emotional overwhelm for therapeutic progress. Pushing harder at that point for emotional experience may be counterproductive, and, in some cases, even harmful.


Knowing When to Slow Down

In ISTDP, therapists pay attention not only to the core emotions a person is feeling, but also to the physiological experience and manifestation of anxiety.


Anxiety in the Body: Yellow and Red Lights

Some physiological anxiety responses suggest that the pace of therapy needs to slow down. For example, anxiety that is discharged into the smooth muscles can manifest as digestive issues such as acid reflux and an upset stomach, which can indicate a yellow light. In these instances, it may be possible to continue to pursue emotional experience, but it is also important to closely monitor anxiety for any signs of it changing or worsening.

Another anxiety response, namely cognitive-perceptual disruption (CPD), involves symptoms such as difficulty thinking clearly, confusion, and disturbances in perception. These are red lights, indicating that regulating anxiety should take priority over further exploration of difficult feelings.


Affect Regulation and Anxiety Regulation in ISTDP: Finding a Manageable Threshold

The aim of psychotherapy is not to eliminate anxiety altogether. It is a common misconception that psychotherapy aims to reduce or eliminate anxiety. Some anxiety may accompany meaningful emotional work, and, when anxiety is within a certain threshold, it can be extremely useful to notice, as it is an indicator of underlying, usually unconscious, wishes or impulses that are driving the anxiety. Anxiety is healthy and can be a core component of effective psychotherapy if the person also remains sufficiently able to experience, reflect upon and learn from what is happening, and notice their emotional experience.


A useful comparison comes from a concept in learning theory: the zone of proximal development. This describes a window where a challenge is just within someone's reach and where one can grow and learn from facing difficult emotions. When one is outside their zone of proximal development, experiencing difficult emotions is likely to overwhelm existing abilities.


Psychotherapy can work in a similar way whereby the challenge needs to be manageable enough for the person to participate in it. It is also important that, when re-experiencing challenging feelings that have been warded off, the individual feels they can do something healthy and productive with the feelings, rather than feeling helpless in the face of them in a way that might mirror the original trauma.



Containment Is More Than Reassurance

Regulating anxiety is not simply a matter of offering reassurance to someone or helping them to "calm down". Anxiety regulation also involves helping an individual to learn over time that they can tolerate and be present with emotional experiences that once felt intolerable and had to, at one point, be warded off for survival.


Bion's Theory of Containment

This links to the concept of containment, introduced by the psychoanalyst Wilfred Bion, to describe a process whereby overwhelming emotional experiences gradually become manageable through another person's capacity (in this instance, the therapist's) to receive and think about such experiences.

In early development, a child usually depends upon a parent or caregiver to help make sense of feelings that are not yet understandable.


Over time, provided they have sufficient containing experiences, they should develop a greater capacity to contain and think about those experiences independently. When this happens, the child has achieved a developmental milestone in the sense that they have taken in the capacity to contain their own distressing experiences.


A similar process to the above is thought to happen in dynamic psychotherapy. When someone is experiencing emotional distress, the presence of another who can remain thoughtful and engaged can help them to begin to view whatever it is they are feeling as something bearable. This process illustrates containment, whereby the experience of a thoughtful and engaged other communicates to the individual that distressing feelings can be thought about, understood and metabolised. In contrast to this, when another person communicates in some way that the feeling must be got rid of (e.g. the therapist themselves seems distressed), they are communicating that the experience is uncontainable. In this instance, the individual has been deprived of the opportunity to learn that distressing experiences can be approached with care and curiosity.


Caroline Garland, in her writing about psychological trauma, describes how traumatic experiences can be so overwhelming that they interfere with a person's capacity to think about what has happened to them. The difficulty is not necessarily only that the memory itself is painful, but that attempting to remember or make sense of the experience may elicit a level of distress that the individual cannot tolerate and that makes it difficult for them to reflect upon what has happened.


In this respect, the purpose of containment is to help the individual gradually build a greater capacity to remain in contact with painful emotional experiences, whilst still being able to think about and make sense of them.

From Overwhelming Sensation to Something Thinkable

Garland also draws upon the concept of symbolisation, which refers to a person’s capacity to recognise that a feeling, memory or image is a representation of something that has been experienced, as opposed to being the experience itself.


Flashbacks and Psychic Equivalence

For example, consider the difference between recalling a frightening event and experiencing the recollection of the event as though it is actually happening again in the present.


During a traumatic flashback, the distinction between remembering something and actually re-experiencing it can become blurred. A person may experience the memory not simply as something that happened in the past, but as though the danger or threat associated with it is happening all over again.


This has some similarities with the concept of psychic equivalence in mentalization theory. Psychic equivalence refers to when what is experienced internally, such as a thought, feeling or image, is experienced as though it is a direct representation of external reality. 


Developing a greater capacity for symbolisation may help someone to recognise that, although the feelings associated with a memory are very real, the experience they relate to is not necessarily occurring in the present. This does not mean that the memory becomes less important, or that the emotions associated with it simply disappear. Rather, it may become possible for the person to experience these feelings whilst also being able to recognise and think about what is happening inside them.


This is also one of the reasons why regulating anxiety can be so important in psychotherapy. When someone becomes sufficiently overwhelmed that they are no longer able to think about what they are experiencing, encouraging them to experience their emotions more intensely may not necessarily be helpful. In some circumstances, it may simply lead to further overwhelm.



Making Room for Feelings Without Becoming Overwhelmed

In ISTDP, the aim is to help people recognise, experience and understand emotions that may previously have been difficult to acknowledge or tolerate. However, an important part of this work is recognising how much anxiety a person is experiencing, and whether they are able to remain sufficiently present and reflective whilst approaching difficult feelings.


Some people may be able to approach these feelings relatively directly, whereas others may need more time to develop the capacity to recognise their anxiety, remain emotionally present and gradually experience emotions that have previously felt overwhelming.


There is no single pace that is appropriate for everyone. A person's history, current difficulties, capacity to regulate anxiety and reasons for seeking therapy all need to be taken into consideration when deciding how to proceed.


The aim is therefore not necessarily to encourage the strongest possible emotional response, but to help someone develop the capacity to experience and understand difficult feelings whilst retaining the ability to think about what they are experiencing.


Ultimately, successful therapy is not about erasing painful memories, anxiety or emotions.

Rather, it is about gaining greater freedom to experience anxiety-generating emotion so one knows how one wants to respond, and so one can better understand one's reactions and how they relate to others, even when the past cannot be undone.


Selected References

British Psychoanalytical Society (n.d.) Wilfred Bion: Biographical and Theoretical Overview.

Frederickson, J. (n.d.) Self Supervision. ISTDP Institute.

Garland, C. (1991) 'External disasters and the internal world: An approach to psychotherapeutic understanding of survivors', in Holmes, J. (ed.) Textbook of Psychotherapy in Psychiatric Practice. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone, pp. 507–532.

Whittemore, J. W. (1996) 'Paving the royal road: An overview of conceptual and technical features in the graded format of Davanloo's Intensive Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy', International Journal of Short-Term Psychotherapy, 11, pp. 21–39.

 
 
BACP Membership
BPC Membership

​​

© Copyright 2026 Jake Freedman. All Rights Reserved.

bottom of page