Knowing What You Feel and Feeling It: Isolation of Affect and Emotional Indwelling in Psychodynamic Therapy
Knowing What You Feel and Feeling It: Isolation of Affect and Emotional Indwelling in Psychodynamic Therapy
When someone says they know they are angry, what exactly is it that they know? They may know that somebody has treated them unfairly, remember having felt angry at the time, or recognise anger as the most appropriate name for their response. None of these necessarily tells us what they are experiencing as they speak. In psychodynamic psychotherapy, isolation of affect describes a defence that allows someone to think quite clearly about an upsetting experience whilst feeling little of the emotion associated with it. They might be able to explain precisely why a person they love has hurt them. When asked about their experience of anger, they find themselves explaining what happened again.
A missed evening and the question of anger
Someone is preparing two margaritas, taking particular care with the rims of the glasses. The chilli salt has to stick, so they rub a piece of lime around each tumbler. Some of the juice finds a raw patch of skin beside their thumb, and they swear. Then their phone lights up with a message from their partner, who has to work late and won’t be home when they promised. They respond, ‘No problem. x’, and put the phone down beside the drinks. There is a sudden heat in their face, and their stomach seems to tighten. They look at their thumb, where the lime is still stinging, and start trying to get the last grains of salt off the kitchen counter. They drink their margarita, then their partner’s. Later, the tequila comes out. By the time their partner gets home, they’re out on the couch.
What exactly happened between their partner texting and the tequila?
Feelings, anxiety and psychological defences
Here I invoke Malan's Triangle of Conflict to offer a way of understanding what might have happened between receiving the message and passing out on the couch. The triangle offers a framework for understanding how underlying emotions can stir up anxiety, and how psychological defences, which often operate outside of our awareness, may interfere with our ability to experience those emotions. Perhaps the individual felt angry when their partner cancelled, but then began to feel guilty because they knew their partner was having a difficult day. Their shoulders tighten, although they're now looking at the cut on their thumb. The lime and chilli really have hurt them, so paying attention to the thumb is hardly surprising. But I think we could also wonder whether something happened to their experience of anger at that moment. If they later said, ‘Of course I was angry. Anyone would be’, we wouldn't know whether this was an account of their own feeling or a judgement about what someone in their position might reasonably feel. That distinction could be worth exploring.

How isolation of affect can protect relationships
One possible explanation for isolation of affect lies in what happens when anger is directed towards somebody on whom we also depend. Imagine a child whose mother responds to complaints by becoming silent, or by telling the child how hurt she is. The child may still know that they are angry, but their attention might become increasingly occupied with whether they have upset their mother and what they need to do to repair things between them. Over time, the child may become more accustomed to thinking about the reasons for their anger than experiencing the feeling itself. This could provide some protection against the guilt and anxiety associated with being angry towards somebody they love. In adulthood, the same person may be able to explain precisely why their partner has upset them, whilst finding themselves more concerned with their partner's feelings than their own. They may know that something unfair has happened, yet struggle to connect with the anger sufficiently to understand what they want to say to their partner.
Experiencing emotions in the body in ISTDP
In intensive short-term dynamic psychotherapy (ISTDP), we are interested in how a feeling is experienced in the body as it arises towards another person. In Reaching Through Resistance, the psychiatrist Allan Abbass describes a man sitting with his hands clenched as he talks about a disagreement with his wife. He knows he is angry with her. Asked how he experiences the anger physically, he replies, ‘I’m very, very tense.’ Abbass understands the tension as anxiety about being angry with his wife. A little later the man explains that he starts to ignore her. What the anger itself feels like is still hard for him to say. The therapist Jon Anders Lied describes an ‘insulating gap’ between the cognitive and bodily aspects of a feeling. A person can give a remarkably precise account of their body from the thinking side of that gap.
Emotional indwelling and nondual awareness
Judith Blackstone: inhabiting the body
In The Fullness of the Ground, the psychotherapist and meditation teacher Judith Blackstone asks readers to rest their hands in their laps and notice how warm or cold they are. Then she offers a curious instruction. ‘Now enter into your hands, inhabit them.’ I take this to mean that a person can attend to a bodily sensation whilst still feeling somewhat separate from it. In Blackstone's account, inhabiting the body is part of a much wider practice of nondual awareness, concerned with the experience of continuity within oneself and with one's surroundings. There is no reason to assume that experiencing an emotion in psychotherapy amounts to the same thing.
Willa Blythe Baker: the experiential body and somatic bypass
Willa Blythe Baker makes a related observation in The Wakeful Body. She distinguishes the body we hold in mind, with all its descriptions and judgements, from the body we experience in the present moment. Baker also considers how meditation itself can become a way of avoiding difficult bodily feelings, something she calls ‘somatic bypass’. I think this is particularly relevant to psychotherapy because paying attention to one's body does not necessarily mean that one is becoming more emotionally present. Baker describes a woman who could enter a blissful state she thought of as ‘pure consciousness’, during which her body and its problems seemed to disappear. Yet her difficulties with her body returned when the meditation ended. The experience had provided temporary relief without resolving her troubled relationship with her body.

Emotional indwelling in psychodynamic psychotherapy
I would borrow the idea of inhabiting the body for a more modest purpose in psychotherapy. By emotional indwelling I mean feeling an emotion from within as it takes shape towards somebody in particular. Suppose the person who made the margaritas is describing the evening to their therapist. If they think about their partner now, perhaps they become aware of wanting to tell them how much they had been looking forward to the evening. Yet this wish may also stir up guilt because they know how difficult their partner's working day was. In psychotherapy, I would want to understand whether the individual can experience their anger towards their partner whilst also being aware of their concern for them, or whether the anxiety and guilt associated with the anger interfere with their ability to experience it.
From emotional protection to conscious choice
Understanding an emotion and having the direct experience of it from the inside refer to two different forms of knowing. Isolation of affect may originally have helped an individual preserve an important early attachment relationship, particularly where experiencing anger towards somebody on whom they depended became associated with guilt or the fear of losing that relationship. In psychotherapy, we would want to understand what function this defence originally served, whether it continues to be necessary, and what consequences it may have when the individual uses it in a rigid fashion. An important distinction here is that experiencing an emotion does not necessarily mean that one must express it or act upon it. They may feel their anger towards somebody they love and decide to let the matter pass. Their own objection can now enter into that decision, alongside everything they already understand about the other person.
References
Abbass, A. (2015). Reaching Through Resistance: Advanced Psychotherapy Techniques. Seven Leaves Press, pp. 12–14.
Baker, W. B. (2021). The Wakeful Body: Somatic Mindfulness as a Path to Freedom. Shambhala, ch. 2.
Blackstone, J. (2023). The Fullness of the Ground: A Guide to Embodied Awakening. Sounds True, introduction and ch. 6.
Lied, J. A. (2025). An Introduction to Intensive Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy: Foundations of Clinical Practice. Routledge, ch. 14.
Malan, D. and Coughlin Della Selva, P. (2006). Lives Transformed: A Revolutionary Method of Dynamic Psychotherapy. Karnac Books, pp. 10–11.


