The Psychodynamics of Trauma and ISTDP: Understanding What Remains After the Event
The Psychodynamics of Trauma: Understanding What Remains After the Event
A traumatic experience may end, yet its effects can continue to shape how someone feels, responds to others and makes sense of everyday situations. Two people can live through the same frightening event and emerge with very different reactions. Psychodynamic therapy asks not only what happened, but what the experience came to mean to this particular person. Intensive Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy (ISTDP), a form of psychodynamic treatment, brings special attention to the feelings, anxiety and protective responses that emerge in the present, including within the therapeutic relationship.
How trauma can continue after the event
An event is not the whole story
Trauma can involve overwhelming events, but its psychological effects also depend on how the experience is processed and understood.
When danger continues to feel present
Think of trauma as a fear state that someone has become frozen in. Although the event may be over, the person may still feel as though they have to fight their way out of a threatening situation, or that they need to flee it. There can be a state of agitation in the body, without an obvious danger in the room.
During a distressing experience, the individual may have had feelings or impulses they could not safely express, such as wanting to fight or get away. Some of those responses may then become associated with danger, so that even approaching the feeling brings anxiety. Earlier experiences can also shape how they react now, before they have words for it. We still need to find out what the reaction means for this person.
It's useful to distinguish fear of actual danger, fear of perceived danger, and anxiety arising from our own feelings or impulses. An anxious reaction in the body may relate to something the person has learned to fear inside themselves, but don't assume that in advance just because they have a physical symptom.

Noticing the filter between past and present
Imagine wearing invisible sunglasses unawares. Since you don't know the glasses are there, what is internal can feel as though it belongs to, or is happening in, the outside world. This filter of experiencing the world through these invisible sunglasses can then influence not only how you see the world, but what you feel you need to do within it.
Then imagine that these are invisible 'smoke-tinged' spectacles that survived a fire and are picking up traces from a man's vape outside a café. The person sees the vape cloud and starts to panic unless they become aware of the glasses.
Awareness helps them know that their experience may be filtered so they can stop and ask, 'Okay, what's really happening around me? Let me reorient myself to the present. I am sitting outside a café and nothing bad is happening. The man next to me is just vaping. At this particular moment, I am as certain as I can be that I am safe.'
Now, recognition alone that it's a filtered reaction doesn't necessarily make the panic or fear disappear. What changes is that they can begin to question whether the danger they feel is the whole picture.
One key task of therapy is to begin noticing the glasses, that is, to distinguish what is happening internally from what is happening externally, and to experience feelings without being governed by the old sense of danger.
A one-off catastrophe versus a relational injury
Trauma can arise from a one-off catastrophe, such as an accident or natural disaster, from harm inflicted by another person, or from repeated experiences of fear or insecurity within close relationships. These are not interchangeable experiences, and none is inherently more “real” than another. The distinction helps us ask what the event meant to the person, what support was available and whether it stirred earlier expectations of danger or abandonment.
Trauma doesn't need to look like a flashback
Anxiety, numbness, low mood, relationship difficulties, bodily symptoms, or habitual avoidance may be part of the picture. Someone might go about their day, but with much of their attention still focused on watching for danger. That might involve muscular tension, disturbances in the body, periods of feeling mentally foggy or disconnected, or avoiding experiences that bring back traumatic memories. Of course, hypervigilance, low mood, or feeling disconnected can have other causes.
Why two people can respond differently to the same event
Two people may survive the same disaster but experience its aftermath quite differently. For one, the event may be terrifying yet gradually become something they can remember and talk about. For another, it may connect with earlier experiences of helplessness, fear or being left without comfort, so that the sense of danger persists long after the immediate threat has passed. As Caroline Garland suggests, an external disaster may join up with an existing internal world and reawaken fears that are difficult to put into words.
What happens afterwards matters too. A person who has dependable relationships, practical help and room to make sense of the experience may have different resources from someone who faces isolation or further uncertainty. Neither response is a measure of character or strength. Understanding the difference means paying attention to the person’s history, present circumstances and particular emotional experience, rather than assuming the event alone explains everything.
Protective responses and emotional memory
When protection becomes a problem
Emotional distancing, avoidance, or detachment can protect a person when feelings are overwhelming, but an old solution may later restrict life.
A behaviour or defence that was once adaptive in a formative relationship may continue into adult life, when the attachment need remains but withdrawing now interferes with closeness.
The purpose isn't to criticise someone for their use of once-adaptive defences, but to understand what they were protecting against, what they're costing the person now, and whether the person is ready to relinquish them.
The hidden cost of not feeling
The issue is not simply remembering a distressing event; feelings may be difficult to recognize or tolerate in current life.
There is a difference between being able to tell the story of a distressing experience and being able to feel what is bound up with it. Through this lens, the person's reluctance to face feelings makes a great deal of sense.
In ISTDP, the goal isn't to retrieve a memory. The focus is more on what happens in the present, in relation to another person, when those feelings approach awareness, and whether the person can begin to experience them safely.
Early relational expectations can therefore reappear in adult relationships, even when someone consciously wants something different. This does not mean that people choose harmful relationships; it means that familiar emotional patterns can be difficult to recognise and change.
Two reasons why the past can appear in the present
1. The past may be felt without accompanying narration as to what happened. ISTDP expert Robert Neborsky emphasizes implicit emotional and attachment learning—that a reaction can be powerful even when someone cannot neatly explain it.
2. The current relationship can reactivate old expectations. A present-day disagreement or moment of intimacy may stir feelings linked to earlier relationships. The trigger is current—the emotional pattern may be far in the past.
Why a flashback can feel like “now”
What matters here is the distinction between remembering an experience and experiencing it as though it is actually happening again.
British psychoanalyst and clinical psychologist Caroline Garland emphasizes the distinction between recalling an event and experiencing it as if it is occurring again, through the lens of containment and symbolisation.
During a flashback, the survivor may not have the ordinary 'as if' quality that lets us say, 'This reminds me of something terrible.' For the survivor, the flashback doesn't just stand for or represent the disaster; it is the disaster all over again. That's the difference between recalling something and reliving it.
There's also a distinction between visual flashbacks and what people sometimes call 'emotional flashbacks'. Someone may feel shame, humiliation, or bodily anxiety without seeing a picture from the past. But not every negative or distressing emotional response is a flashback. The more relevant question is whether the person feels immersed in something that represents or symbolizes a distressing or traumatizing experience, or whether something is happening to them now that is genuinely upsetting or threatening.
What does ISTDP contribute to the treatment of trauma?
ISTDP attends to emotional experience, anxiety, and protective patterns occurring now. It does not assume repeated telling alone creates change.
In all forms of psychotherapy, the person can revisit experiences and begin to feel feelings that could not safely be experienced or expressed at the time. But the work also happens in what occurs in the here and now between therapist and patient.
For example, a core feeling may begin to emerge, anxiety rises and the person looks away or becomes detached. Rather than treating that response as a failure, the therapist can draw attention to what has just happened and explore it together with the patient, at a pace they can tolerate.
Malan's triangle of conflict and the psychodynamics of trauma, in plain English
Feeling or impulse → anxiety → defence.
This illustrates how someone can move away from a painful feeling without noticing.
We all have feelings and impulses, anxiety about those feelings and impulses, and then defences against that anxiety. For example, in an argument, one person may go blank. They may manage this relational conflict by retreating, stonewalling, or leaving the room.
On the other hand, if they have a different attachment style, they may lash out, and the anger here might be protecting them from a deeper fear.
The Feelings beneath the symptoms
Back to Robert Neborsky for a moment …His clinical model explores underlying grief, anger, guilt, and shame. These are possibilities to investigate collaboratively in therapy. They are not feelings to ascribe to every survivor.
Another way to understand conflict in ISTDP is how to explore whatever is happening for the individual. Withdrawal may then serve a purpose, but whether it is protective in this relationship, now, is something we'd still have to find out.

The therapeutic relationship is not incidental
The patient may experience anxiety or defensive responses in the room, but both patient and therapist examine feelings as they arise.
Something can happen in the room between a therapist and a client which, for the client, feels far more threatening than it appears from the outside.
When the therapeutic relationship feels unsafe
One example could be a man who has had frightening experiences with his father and comes to see a male therapist. He may find himself feeling unsafe or wanting to withdraw, without necessarily being able to articulate why this is. It would be a mistake, though, to simplify this as him seeing his father in his therapist.
This is why it would be too simple to say that the client is merely “seeing his father” in the therapist. The therapist’s actual behaviour matters as well. A silence might feel hostile, or a question intrusive; the therapist may also have misunderstood something or been genuinely misattuned. These possibilities can be explored together, provided the person is not overwhelmed by anxiety.
Containment without imposing meaning
Containment is part of this work: feelings that once seemed unacceptable may become possible to experience in the presence of someone who can receive them without punishment or retaliation. That is quite different from telling a person what they must be feeling.
In closing: Anxiety regulation is part of the work
Working with emotion is not identical to pushing for the strongest possible reaction. The therapist needs to assess and respond to the person's capacity to tolerate emotional experience.
The goal is never to erase memory.
It is to have more freedom to experience emotion, understand reactions and relate to others, even when the past can't be undone.
About the Authors
Jake Freedman is a psychodynamic therapist working in Fitzrovia, Central London. His main areas of experience and interest are in states of depersonalisation and derealisation, relational trauma, and trauma-related dissociation.
Kathryn Levison is a psychoanalytically-informed freelance writer/editor with a focus on psychology and human nature.
References
Abbass, A. (2015). Reaching Through Resistance.
Abrahams, D., & Rohleder, P. (2021). A Clinical Guide to Psychodynamic Psychotherapy. Routledge. (Chapters 2 and 7.)
Bateman, A., Fonagy, P., Campbell, C., Luyten, P., & Debbané, M. (2023). Trauma. In Cambridge Guide to Mentalization-Based Treatment (MBT) (Chapter 11, pp. 277–297). Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108896054.012
British Psychoanalytical Society. (n.d.). “Wilfred Bion.” Biographical resource.
Frederickson, J. (n.d.). Self Supervision. ISTDP Institute. Clinical teaching resource.
Freedman, J. (2026, 22 October). Garland reading notes, dialogue archive and contributions on participation, pacing, and the psychodynamics of trauma. Unpublished source material.
Garland, C. (1991). External disasters and the internal world: An approach to psychotherapeutic understanding of survivors. In J. Holmes (Ed.), Textbook of Psychotherapy in Psychiatric Practice (pp. 507–532). Churchill Livingstone.
Garland, C. (Ed.). (1998). Understanding Trauma: A Psychoanalytical Approach.
Lingiardi, V., & McWilliams, N. (Eds.). (2017). Psychodynamic Diagnostic Manual (2nd ed.).
McWilliams, N. (2011). Psychoanalytic Diagnosis: Understanding Personality Structure in the Clinical Process (2nd ed.).
Neborsky, R. J. (2003). A Clinical Model for the Comprehensive Treatment of Trauma Using an Affect Experiencing–Attachment Theory Approach. Supplied chapter.
Neborsky, R. J. (2006). Brain, mind, and dyadic change processes. Journal of Clinical Psychology: In Session, 62(5), 523–538. https://doi.org/10.1002/jclp.20246
Neborsky, R. J., & Peluso, E. (n.d.). Identifying and Overcoming the Punitive Superego in Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy.
Rüfenacht, E., Shaverin, L., Stubley, J., Smits, M. L., Bateman, A., Fonagy, P., & Luyten, P. (2023). Addressing dissociation symptoms with trauma-focused mentalization-based treatment. Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy, 37(4), 467–491. https://doi.org/10.1080/02668734.2023.2272765
Terry, P. (2023). A Clinician’s Guide to Understanding and Using Psychoanalysis in Practice.
Whittemore, J. W. (1996). Paving the royal road: An overview of conceptual and technical features in the graded format of Davanloo’s intensive short-term dynamic psychotherapy. International Journal of Short-Term Psychotherapy, 11, 21–39.


